Goodreads | Amazon US| Barnes & Noble | Book Depository
ARC provided by the publisher via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review.
Friends, this just was not the book for me. And you know I hate writing “negative” reviews, so I’m going to try to keep this on the shorter side. But this book and the writing was just equal parts boring and daunting for me. Plus, the magic system was not explained, the characters were hard to like or believe, and I never cared enough to root for any of them. But I think what ultimately made me not love this book was because I went in thinking that we were going to see a crew of queer pirates, on the open sea, fighting battles, slaying monsters, and doing pirate things. This is not the type of book These Rebel Waves is. But on a positive note, this is a book filled with colonization, oppression, magical medical experimentation, religious hierarchies, political intrigue, betrayals, and what people are willing to do in the name of their God(s). And, it sort of has pirates.
And I don’t think that this was a bad book. I mean, obviously many of those topics are super important, but I went into this book just expecting something completely different. And I will totally take responsibility for that. But this book was also super boring, and it felt like a chore to pick up each and every time. I had to constantly reward myself with treats while reading. If this wasn’t an ARC, and if I wasn’t buddy reading this with two of my friends, I would have 100% DNFed this story. And that has nothing to do with the expectations of gay pirates.
And, full disclosure, one of the first books I ever DNFed was Sara Raasch’s Ice Life Fire, so maybe this author’s writing just isn’t for me. So, if you pick this one up, I hope you enjoy it more than I did. But I should probably give you some bare bones about the actual story and the three characters we follow!
➽ Adeluna / Lu – Soldier. Loyal to her family. Experiencing so much loss, and so much trauma, from childhood to present day.
➽ Devereux / Vex – Pirate. Master of disguise. Hinted that he’s queer, maybe even pan, but never stated.
➽ Benat / Ben – Heretic. Crown Prince. Obsessed with the magic that is forbidden. Queer, in a hidden m/m relationship. Also, I don’t know how I feel about the way Ben’s relationship developed, but I kind of don’t want to think about it or this book any longer.
And these characters are all on the same island and their three stories intertwine to maybe change the fate of the world as they know it. And each of these characters have to make choices that will truly decide what type of person they want to be.
In this world, magic is plant based and outlawed. But the thing is, the magic system is never explained. You just have to suspend your disbelief that it works some magical way for some people with the right reagents. I mean, I guess I’d say it’s like magic herbology. I guess? I don’t even know, because it’s so not explained. But anyone who uses this magic will be punished in the name of the Pious God.
Trigger and content warnings for death, murder, loss of a loved one, torture, colonization, physical abuse, child abuse, captivity, medical experimentation, and violence.
And there is also a disease that is killing people rapidly, that needs to be addressed. It’s called the Shaking Sickness, and Lu has felt the heartbreak from it many times. There is no treatment for it, it has no known cause, and it doesn’t spread from person to person. Some people die from it instantly, and other suffer with it for a long while.
So, we have magical plants, and a disease that is killing a lot of people. We have a pirate who is a smooth talker. We have a soldier who has been a soldier all her life, even when forced as a child. And we have a prince, who is dealing with the ghosts from his past. All these things come into play and send Lu and Vex on an adventure, and leaves Ben discovering the hypocrisy of the religion on the island.
My favorite thing about this book was a plot twist. Obviously, I’m not going to give any spoilers, but a certain plot twist in this book was so well done. The author expertly wove it into the entire story, and it is the reason I’m giving this book two stars instead of one. Seriously, it was amazingly done. And the next favorite thing was a beautiful f/f relationship involving two main side characters.
I know that the copy I read was an ARC version, but this book ends so abruptly. I felt like after the amazing plot twist, and finally seeing all the action form and start to take place, we are just cut off. Curtains drawn, lights out. I just sat with my iPad in my lap, blinking a few times, because I thought maybe I got an unfinished ARC. So, here is your warning that the ending is a little brutal.
Overall, this just wasn’t for me. I went in expecting so much and was given so little. And even with so little, it was so different than what I was expecting. I do predict that the next book in this series will be better. I just don’t think I’ll be picking it up. And if you go into this expecting gay pirates, sailing the seas and fighting for injustice, like I did, you’re going to be disappointed. Again, I hate feeling so negative, so I hope that if you give this one a try that you will enjoy it much more than me! Happy reading, loves.
Instagram | Bloglovin’ | Twitter | Tumblr | Goodreads | Twitch
meltotheany 
This is one of my highly anticipated books, and it saddens me that you didn’t enjoy it. I totally know what you mean about expecting one thing and being surprised by getting something else, so thank you for sharing what themes are prevalent. I will still give this a read, but will probably borrow it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, thank you for this comment, love. Yeah, I went in with TOO high of hopes! I should have known better! But I hope you still really enjoy this one, babe! And I’m wishing you happy reading always! 💗xx
LikeLike
I’ve wanted to read this so badly. I have edelweiss but haven’t jumped into using it yet.
I get how it can be as let down when you had your expectations set. Often a book like this, the sequel is much better. I will still have to read this sometime. Thanks for your in depth review.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, thank YOU for your kind words, love! EW is so…. not fun to use? But it is so rewarding, honestly. And I have high hopes for book two of this series! I hope you’re having happy reading! 💗xx
LikeLike
I’ll get around to using it eventually.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My friend did a really good blog post about it, too! If you’re interested! Happy reading, love! ❤ https://wordpress.com/read/blogs/119431242/posts/10858
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is such a wonderful review! I hope your next read will be better, though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, thank you, Hannah love! You are too kind! And I hope you’re having the happiest of reading, love! 💗xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
God I really disliked her “Snow Like Ashes” and it sounds like the exact problems I had with her debut bled into this one. Not explaining the magic system, dull writing, etc. I don’t think she’s for me. I had a similar problem with “Wintersong”, so oh well. I hope your next read is better and never, NEVER apologize for giving your honest opinion. We have the right to express our opinion. If people say you can’t because they don’t like negative reviews rofl firstly, a review is about critiquing something, and secondly, no one has to conform to like what someone else likes. It sucks people harassed you on GR for writing a few neg reviews and I think it’s ridiculous. So you do you. You know what you’re talking about and I’m honestly sick and tired of seeing endless praise and hype for books and no critiques for it :p I end up feeling like I wasted so much time and $ when people hype up books so much and it ends up being meh.
LikeLiked by 2 people
You are such a blessing. Seriously. You have no idea how much confidence this comment gave me. Thank you. And yes, yes to everything to said. 💗xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve been so excited for this book since I heard about it – it’s a shame you didn’t enjoy it! But I’ll definitely being lowering my expectations for it because I was expecting a lot of pirate action as well!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, thank you, love! I do hope you love it, babe! Happy reading! 💗xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have to read this one by next month and I’m a bit worried. I was hoping for lots of pirates. Maybe it will be ok for me now that I know it’s not that type of book. But I also don’t do well with boring books. I am just hoping I can get through it. Great review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, I’m sorry if I made you scared! I hope you enjoy it more and I’m sending you all the well wishes! It really isn’t *bad* by any means, just… not what I thought, I suppose! SO HOPEFULLY it works for you, my love! Happy reading and thank you for always being so amazing! 💗xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! I’m hoping it’s at least ok for me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really enjoyed Snow Like Ashes but I read it when I was just getting back into fantasy a few years ago, and I don’t think it’ll hold up if I read it again. I’m on the fence about continuing with the trilogy, but I don’t think I’m going to read this one because I’m not all that into pirates and I don’t really remember anything super special about her writing style.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really enjoyed book one, I think. I think it was book two I DNFed! So… SAME AND I FEEL YOU! It’s been too long! Haha! But yeah, I really wanted to love this one, Cailin! Ahhh! Too many books, too little time. True? And I hope whatever you’re reading now is five star worthy! 💗xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m sorry this book was a disappointment for you! I liked Sara Raasch’s Snow Like Ashes but it isn’t my favorite series. I loved this book’s synopsis and it’s too bad that the story didn’t live up to it. Great review, though! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, thank you so much for this comment, Raven. And for always being such a damn sweetheart! 💛xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m sorry you didn’t like this book. I love the way you reviewed it, though. Not being cruel in you review, and trying to point out the good along with the bad.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awh, thank you so much. This comment means a lot to me. I always try so hard not to be too negative. I know not every book is for me, but every book is for someone, you know? Hehe. But I hope whatever you’re reading now is five star worthy! 💗xx
LikeLiked by 1 person